Published:
19 October 2023
Categories:
Digital Insights
Reading time:
3 minutes

Reduce or remove the need for sign-off in design projects to improve project flow and stakeholder satisfaction. Learn why a robust process and user-centered approach can lead to better design decisions.

Better User Experiences with AI

Join Paul Boag for 4 live online sessions in November and learn how to use AI to understand your users, improve what you build and design AI features people trust. Early-bird tickets are £195 + VAT until 30 October.

Book your place →

Hello everyone.

A couple of emails back, I shared with you what I considered the most controversial advice I give – to never say no to clients. Well, in this email, I want to follow up with another piece of advice that makes many people wince when I suggest it: stop continually requesting sign-off from stakeholders, especially for design.

I can feel every designer reading this tensing up as I write. Getting sign-off on a design approach before moving on to the build feels so intrinsic to your process that the idea of not doing it feels like insanity.

Asking for design sign-off causes more problems than it solves.

However, how much does it really help? Does it stop stakeholders from asking for design changes post-sign-off? Not as often as you would like, no doubt. They still ask, and then you have to say no or charge them more, which damages the relationship and causes resentment that starts impacting the project in lots of little ways.

But more importantly, asking for sign-off from stakeholders escalates the stakes. Suddenly, getting the design “perfect” becomes critical. They start asking for more and more changes in seeking perfection because they know this is their last chance. They rack their brains for every slight imperfection and ask random people what they think, all to ensure the design is as good as possible before signing it off.

Of course, we know a design is never perfect and that this endless iteration ultimately damages the design. But hopefully, you can see their point of view. They have one shot at this and want to get it right.

A process works better than a sign-off.

By contrast, if you have a robust process that includes testing, you can move on to that step when everybody feels ready. Getting broad, informal agreement that the design is heading in the right direction is enough.

You can reassure stakeholders that any concerns can be validated with testing and that making minor changes during the build is okay. Because, in fact, that is the truth. Tweaking color, typography, and even layout is relatively easy during the build. The design doesn’t need to be one hundred percent locked down. We are not talking about a design about to go to print.

As a brief aside, if you are thinking of redesigning or rebuilding your website, I strongly encourage you to conduct a robust discovery phase and seriously consider how the project is run and how stakeholders will be managed. Traditional project management approaches don’t work well for digital services. You might even want to email me, as I often help organizations prepare for website redesigns.

Removing sign-off lowers the stakes.

Taking this approach does two things.

First, stakeholders relax and tend to be much more comfortable with proceeding with something despite a few niggling concerns.

Second, many of those niggling concerns evaporate as the project progresses, and stakeholders never return to them. In other words, they forget what they were worried about by the time you are deep in the build. However, if you had insisted on sign-off when those concerns were still fresh in their minds, you would have had to act upon them.

Users, not stakeholders, should approve the design.

But setting aside all of the psychology of how sign-off makes stakeholders feel, it is just the right thing to do. Ultimately, a design should be approved by users through testing and not based on the foibles of stakeholders’ personal tastes.

Give it a go and see for yourself.

I know this approach might make you feel uncomfortable. I get it. I still remember the conversation where I was first introduced to the idea and how I couldn’t imagine it working. But it does, and I would encourage you to give it a try on just one project. You will find things go much smoother when you don’t back stakeholders into a corner and insist they sign on the dotted line.

Paul Boag
  • Free access to 3 books including Click! that teaches you how to encourage clicks without shady tricks.
  • Choose between multiple email courses.
  • Choose between in-house or freelancers and agencies content.
  • Learn from an expert with over 30 years experience.

About me

I’m a UX consultant and conversion troubleshooter with 32 years in digital. I help teams create user experiences that work; winning support, improving results, and making change stick.

Contact me

Email: [email protected]
UK Based – Clients in North America, Europe, Asia, Australia.

how I help

  • UX Strategy – Spot what’s blocking a great experience and get a clear plan to fix it.
  • Improving Conversion – Simple, evidence-based changes that make every click count.
  • Coaching & Leadership – A sounding board to help you lead with clarity and confidence.
  • Training & Workshops – Hands-on sessions, playbooks, and self-learning so your team keeps improving.